In both stories Macbeth & Christmas Carol both main characters are presented in different manner which change over the course of the story. Both stories show strong feelings such as guilt, power, and persuasion in very different contexts.
In the opening of the play we are told that Macbeth is a well respected man. “Hail brave friend” this is how Shakespeare introduced Macbeth the reason for this is because Shakespeare wanted us to think that Macbeth is courageous and heroic. However there a small hints during the play that tell us maybe there is another side to Macbeth and that his true colours will be shown.”Which ne’er shook hands, nor bade farewell to him..Till he unseam’d him from the nave to the chaps” Shakespeare used to quotation from the Captain’s description of him in battle to make us question Macbeth’s characteristics and to let us think to who really is Macbeth? We are told Macbeth is a high esteem however the quote is a big clue to what kind of man Macbeth is. The image this creates is of a blood thirsty character who has no remorse to anything this maybe explain Macbeth behaviour later on in the play. The author wanted to show the potential that he had for killing and that there would be no second thoughts in his mind if he had to take a life, foreshadowing what happens later.
In comparison to Christmas Carol, Scrooge is the complete opposite to Macbeth this is seen in the opening parts of the story. Scrooge is portrayed as a heartless selfish man who is very lonely and self centered. He is not involved in the service of others, this is seen when Scrooge meets a charity man who ask Scrooge to donate some money to the poor and needy. ” I don’t make myself merry at Christmas so I cant afford to make the idle happy” This is Scrooge’s flaws that are being presented in the very start of the book, compare to Macbeth where there aren’t any obvious flaws shown. Dickens used this quote to emphasize the fact that Scrooge is a self-serving and dull man, Dickens wanted the first image of Scrooge to be negative in contrast to what he becomes later in the novella. Dickens also decided to give us this evidence early on in the play to give us a small insight to who Scrooge is , his personality and a background of how he’s life was.
At the very start of the soliloquy we start to see Macbeth’s flaws appear and start to see a different side to Macbeth. Macbeth is being manipulated and persuaded by he’s wife Lady Macbeth that he can become the king if he kills the current King, King Duncan. However the soliloquy starts to show small glimpse to who Lady Macbeth is. Macbeth is thinking about he’s consequences towards he’s actions this is seen at the beginning of the soliloquy when he says “Might be the all and the end all here, but here upon this bank and shoot of time we’d jump the life to come” Shakespeare uses this quotation to emphasize how confused Macbeth is, Shakespeare creates an image where Macbeth is in two states of mind whether to proceed with the killing of King Duncan. Another strong feeling created is ambition “We’d jump life to come” Macbeth would risk he’s after life and soul just to become King this tells us he wants to do the killing urgently and would risk anything to do it. This is where Macbeth flaws are starting to be seen , we are being shown that Macbeth is greedy heartless and evil that he would kill King Duncan just so he could could become the next. In this part of the play Macbeth is starting to think in a bad manner and not have any care about anyone besides him and he’s beloved wife Lady Macbeth. Similar to Scrooge, we are told in the beginning of the story the Scrooge is lonely, selfish and rude man who only thinks about himself at this point in both stories both characters have very similar attitudes and characteristic.
Similar to Christmas Carol when Scrooge saw Marley’s ghost for the first ever time. Jacob Marley is the first ghost Scrooge meets, Marley was a business partner of scrooge. Scrooge first saw Marley in he’s door knocker a “horrible appearance with its wild wide open eyes and livid colour” Marley had no bowels and Scrooge could see right through him and could feel the chilling influence of its death cold eyes. Marley informs Scrooge that he will be visited by another three ghost later on in the play. In comparison to Macbeth they are both puzzled that they have seen a ghost for the very first time. both of the characters are apprehensive, this is another flaw and feeling that both authors done. The verb “resolves” creates a image that Macbeth is waiting for something bad to happen, this is where both characters share the same characteristics.hey both are content and feel their beliefs are far more superior. Charles Dickens presents Scrooge in this way to show the audience that Scrooge does feel emotions. This foreshadows later in the play as Scrooge begins to feels more emotions. Dickens wants the reader to fast-think to what this might foreshadow later in the novella.
Later in the play Macbeth has already killed Banquo reasons for Macbeth is suspicious and worried that Banquo would tell someone that Macbeth planned to kill King Duncan as he was there when they found out their fates after coming back from a battle from the three witches. Also he decides to kill Banquo children so they wouldn’t be next to throne after their dead dad. Lady Macbeth & Macbeth decided to throw a big banquet and invite lots of people. At this point of the play Macbeth flaws are becoming more evident to the readers/audience. During the dinner when Banquo ghost appears Macbeth becomes distressed and starts shouting this is demonstrated when Macbeth says”I am in blood stepped in so far, that, should I wade no more, Returning were as tedious as go o’er” This is when Macbeth sees Banquo ghost shortly after he’s death. Shakespeare has used this quote to highlight the fact that what Lady Macbeth& Macbeth done was evil cold hearted and cruel. Shakespeare also decided to present Macbeth like this towards the denouement of the play so the audience would be confused to why Macbeth is acting in this foul manner, as we know Macbeth was presented as a well respected noble man at the beginning of the play so therefore the audience would be really shocked to see Macbeth behave like this. The picture this creates is Macbeth is saying to himself that he is in to deep top what he has done “I am in blood” all Macbeth can see is blood on he’s hand, he has been traumatised by the murder of he’s good friend Banquo. “Should I wade no more” Macbeth feels he is in a puddle of blood that is up to he’s ankles and can hardly move through the blood because there is too much. Returning were as tedious as go o’er” He could turn around, go back to the bank of that river of blood, but it’s too late. He’s half way across, so he keeps going. Seeing Macbeth stepping deep into the river of blood that he has himself created, trudging across, getting tired but realizing he can’t go back, is to feel the horror and despair that he must feel.
Coming to the end of the play Macbeth is totally lost and has completely lost his mind making him go insane and not knowing what to do. He has committed so many crimes and the peer-pressure really affected him to do things he never wished he had done. Also Banquo’s ghost keeps appearing which frightens Macbeth, activates his insanity and at this moment he is totally flawed. “Approach thou like the rugged Russian bear, The arm’d rhinoceros, or the Hyrcan tiger; Take any shape but that, and my firm nerves, Shall never tremble: or be alive again.” Macbeth demonstrates signs of fear by the apparition of the ghost, it doesn’t matter what shape or form he is in it will still affected the way he acts. Compared to the start of the play where he was described with no fear and had no flaws it has been proved that it was meant to miss lead you and Shakespeare has created two different personalities for one character.
On the other hand Scrooge is becoming a character with no flaws and is becoming a hero is he town due to his actions after he woke up from his dream. Now that Scrooge is trying to prove himself that is has changed and is another man, as the reader we feel content for this behaviour and things that we now found surprising compared to the start of the novella: “I am about to raise your salary”. Used to knowing Scrooge as a tight-fisted and selfish person when we are introduced to one of the most remarkable actions he could of done, raising the salary of his clerk and the audience get a sense of shock in a positive way. The word ‘raise’ tends to a good thing and I feel convinced that Scrooge has changed, because throughout that day he does many other generous things. Dickens wants to show us the true Christmas spirit and people should behave themselves not only during this time of the year but all year round. Also the fact that Scrooge said he was going to change and he did. Actions speak louder than words, is one of the morals Dickens tries to portray to us.
Recent Comments